Debate Time! The Toymakers - Robert Dinsdale

February 16, 2018

Nick and I met up again to have a cup of tea and our usual literary debate; this time, over Robert Disdale’s The Toymakers. We’re both huge fans of magical realism, so approached this book with high expectations. Here’s a brief summary of the plot, plus our thoughts about it.


What’s it All About, Then?


Cathy, a young, pregnant runaway, applies for a job at The Emporium; a mysterious toy shop that only opens at the first frost of winter, and closes when the first snowdrop appears.


It’s a weird and wonderful place, where the toys made by Papa Jack and his two sons, Kaspar and Emil, seem almost alive. However, the magic of The Emporium takes a turn for the darker as Cathy finds herself caught between the two sons, and Kaspar leaves to fight in the war. It’s a bittersweet ending, and one that echoes the sense of wonder that runs through the entire book.



Lucy: We both really wanted to read this one, didn’t we?

Nick: Totally. Christmas magic, toy shops, a rich cast of characters… now, that’s my sort of book. It got off to an absolutely brilliant start, I have to say.

Lucy: Didn’t it just? It was such an evocative, magical opening; setting the scene in this wonderful, richly depicted toy-store – it really took me back to my childhood days, visiting Hamleys at Christmas with my parents.

Nick: I don’t know about that, but I’m certainly with you on the power of those opening pages; I was so pleased as I was reading them, thinking I was in for a real treat. In fact, I’d say the whole first half of the book was excellent, and kept me totally immersed throughout.

Lucy: Yes, me too. I loved how the reader explored the toy shop (and the quirky inhabitants) through Cathy’s eyes, and shared her sense of wonder. I also adored the little secret den that she hid in whilst having her baby – what an imaginative concept, this ‘toy’ house that looks small from the outside, but contains a huge room within! That sense of childlike wonder, and the feeling that anything could happen, worked very well.

Nick: What did you think about Cathy as a protagonist?

Lucy: It’s funny you should ask; because I Ioved her in the first half, then as she grew older, I found her less sympathetic. Perhaps because she lost that sense of wonder, and became more real.

Nick: I’m so glad you said that, because I felt that about the entire second half, not just Cathy. Everything got darker and more ‘real’, but I felt that was a detriment to the rest of the story.

Lucy: I wouldn’t go that far. I thought it was a brave move, to suddenly take the novel in a harsher direction, and for me, it worked. Though admittedly, it was a wrench to leave the lovely safety of the magical Emporium at its most magical.

Nick: Yeah, but that’s exactly the problem – we were sold a ‘magical’ book, but it’s like the spell wore off halfway through!

Lucy: (laughs) Oh, come on, there was lots in the second half that was excellent. What about the sibling rivalry between Emil and Kaspar?

Nick: Alright, fair play; I liked that aspect of it. That felt very convincing. However, now I’m thinking about it more, actually, I found it a bit disappointing too, as it made me like both characters less. 

Lucy: That’s true; I loved Kaspar in the first part of the book; he was so fearless and dashing… but then he lost a lot of himself. However, that’s a necessary part of the plot, isn’t it? We can’t really criticise the author for that.

Nick: I question the decision, myself. It would have been nice to have Kaspar return to his former glory at least, rather than be destroyed by the war.

Lucy: But the war would have destroyed people, surely? That’s a fair representation.

Nick: Yes, I know all that, but you’re getting into another sort of book territory then, aren’t you? That’s what I keep coming back to – this idea that the book is a game of two halves, and I felt a bit cheated by the second.

Lucy: What did you feel about the pace of The Toymakers?

Nick: Great to start with, but a plod around the middle.

Lucy: Now that I can agree with, as I found it exactly the same. I think for me, I started to find it slightly less engaging after Cathy had the baby. And especially after Kaspar had gone to war, as I felt he was a catalyst for a lot of the most interesting action.

Nick: Exactly. But I don’t want to sound like I’m rubbishing this book, because I definitely am not. In fact, there were loads of elements I loved. Sirius the ragdoll dog for starters; now who could resist him? I was so panicked they were going to let him wind down!

Lucy: Ah, he was lovely, wasn’t he? And the little toy soldiers that started thinking independently at the end of the book, I thought that was fab. Makes you think hard about the nature of creation and ownership.

Nick: You’re getting deep again, aren’t you?

Lucy: I always look for a sub-text!

Nick: On this occasion, I think you’re right, I think there’s a lot going on beneath the surface with this book. I just wish the author had cut some of the lengthy descriptions, and kept up the magic a little bit more.

Lucy: Fair enough. What would you give it?

Nick: I’ll go for a very respectable 3.5 / 5 Stars. It was good, but it could have been great.

Lucy: I’m going with a 4.5 / 5 Stars. I enjoyed it, with only minor niggles!



Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Please reload

Featured Posts

I'm busy working on my blog posts. Watch this space!

Please reload

Recent Posts
Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags