Debate Time – What Makes a Good Book?

May 26, 2018

This week, we got together to chat about a fundamental aspect of reading – what makes a good book? Why is it we totally go gaga over one novel, then loathe another?

It was a question that certainly made us ponder hard. Here are the results of our chat!


Lucy: So, we’re talking about what makes a good book. Which seems like quite a difficult question to answer, wouldn’t you say?

Karen: I’m not sure. I’ve got some quite firm ideas about what I love about books, and there are definite characteristics that I look for when I’m seeking out the next novel to read.

Nick: Yeah, I know what you mean. I usually have a strong idea of what I like to read, and I’m not sure how often I step outside that box. Also, I’m a terrible one for judging a book by its cover.

Karen: Totally! It’s the shop window really, isn’t it? The lure that pulls you in, and if it’s not appealing, it won’t inspire me to read it. In fact, that’s why I don’t enjoy reading on a Kindle as much as I do flicking through a hard copy – it doesn’t have that lovely, satisfying cover to hold onto!

Lucy: That’s interesting that you say that. I love it when a cover is artistic and beautiful, and it would make me more likely to take interest. However, I would still read a book if it had a stinking cover, if the description sounded promising. I can think of quite a few awful book covers, concealing wonderful literature inside!

Nick: Ha, you can’t make us sound all shallow like that! Judging a book by its cover is a very normal thing, and I think, by and large, a good cover shows that similar love and attention has been devoted to the contents inside. I loved the front cover to Neil Gaiman’s Norse Mythology so much, I ended up buying several different versions of it.

Lucy: You’re a real purist when it comes to stuff like that. Your collection of signed copies fills me with awe!

Karen: Of course, I would still read a book if the cover was bad, if someone had recommended it to me. But it’d probably have to be recommended.

Nick: What about genres, then? Because let’s be honest; I bet we’ve all got a favourite genre, and we’re far more likely to think a book is ‘good’ if it fits into it.

Karen: I don’t know; I’m one of those people who will try anything. Though I don’t love sci-fi or fantasy so much.

Nick: So, you could equally love a romance book, and a gritty crime novel? One wouldn’t appeal to you more than the other?

Karen: No. I prize a good plot-line and good writing above genre, personally.

Lucy: I’m with you, Karen. Among my favourite books are dystopian literary fiction, sci-fi, teen horror and comedy – as long as it engages me and makes me think about it long after, that’s the main thing!

Nick: Ah, I’m a bit of a creature of habit when it comes to genres. I love fantasy, sci-fi, magical realism and post-modernism. We’re polar opposites in our reading tastes, Karen.

Karen: Which is why it’s great that we’re both reviewers on here – we’re covering all bases!

Nick: Having said that, I am happy to try new stuff. I never say never. Not sure you could convince me to dive into a romantic chick-lit story though.

Lucy: I think we should give you one, to test it out. You might end up loving it.

Nick: Ha, I might. You never know!

Lucy: So, what makes a perfect book, in your opinion?

Karen: The million-dollar question! I love developing characters – where they start in one place and finish somewhere unexpected. That’s so exciting to read. I think ‘human’ characters are wonderful too – characters that you can relate to, that have their own quirks and habits. Agatha Christie’s Poirot is a great example; he’s so eccentric and his brain works in such a unique way, that it’s a pleasure to read.

Lucy: Characters are definitely a big part of it. Karen, we were talking about Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine recently – that’s a fabulous example of a relatable, layered, unique character, don’t you think?

Karen: That book was fantastic. I also loved the way it turned what could have been a tragic story right on its head.

Nick: Everyone keeps going on about that book, I’ll have to read it. I like strong, engaging characters, male or female. I can’t do wishy-washy – I prefer characters that drive the action along, that are big, bold and endlessly fascinating.

Lucy: Neil Gaiman’s a master at writing characters like that.

Nick: Isn’t he just? I like a good baddie too. Not your stereotyped boring baddie, someone who is a rounded character with their own back-story. But also someone who is a real, believable threat.

Karen: I don’t think there’s ever anything wrong with a bit of darkness in a book; it provides a nice balance. Like Jane Eyre, one of my favourite books of all time. It’s a romantic story, but actually, there’s a lot of darkness in it.

Nick:  I love Jane Eyre, and you’re so right about the dark factor. Reading something that is a bit uncomfortable or unsettling, I think that can be fun too. I bet you think so, don’t you Lucy, knowing what your taste in books is like?

Lucy: Definitely! I don’t like to read stuff that’s distasteful or unpleasant for the sake of creating ‘shock value’ but I love books that dare to explore eerie or unsettling subject matter. It’s always obvious when an author has taken a step out of their comfort zone and I respect them for that.

Karen: It goes without saying that a strong plot is usually a good thing.

Nick: Yep. I love books that drag me along with them, kicking and screaming. For me, a good pace is everything. I can’t get along with stodgy, slow writing.

Lucy: Though sometimes it’s good to have a slower pace, so you can reflect on the book a bit more?

Nick: Nah, I like a rip-roaring read!

Lucy: So, favourite books of all time. What are yours, Karen?

Karen: Well, Jane Eyre is right up there, as is Murder on the Orient Express. Anything by Sarah Waters too; particularly Fingersmith. Ooh, and The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern. I don’t know, there are so many to choose from! I could list about fifty straight off, I think.

Nick: Favourite authors is a bit easier, I think. I adore Haruki Murakami, Neil Gaiman, Kurt Vonnegut, Brett Easton Ellis and C Robert Cargill. You introduced me to that last one, Lucy.

Lucy: And you introduced me to Murakami – so I suppose that makes us even! I love Margaret Atwood, especially The Blind Assassin and Oryx & Crake. I also love Neil Gaiman and David Mitchell. Ooh, and I have a huge obsession with Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, which is definitely one of the best books ever written.

Karen: Ah, I could talk about books all day!

Nick: I think we all could. Do you think we’ve got an addiction? Is there a cure for book addiction?

Lucy: We’re all incurable, Nick… there’s no saving us!

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Please reload

Featured Posts

I'm busy working on my blog posts. Watch this space!

Please reload

Recent Posts
Please reload